Starting next spring, a complete
human-genome sequence can be ordered for just $5,000, thanks to a new
sequencing service announced by Complete Genomics,
a startup based in Mountain View, CA. The stunning price
drop--sequencing currently costs approximately 20 times that
amount--could completely change the way that human-genomics research is
done and open up new possibilities in personalized medicine.
Researchers say that a $5,000 genome would enable new studies to
identify rare genetic variants linked to common diseases, and it could
open up the sequencing market to diagnostic and pharmaceutical
companies, making genome sequencing a routine part of clinical drug
testing.
Complete Genomics, which has received $46 million in venture funding
to date and has largely stayed under the radar, plans to launch with a
bang and anticipates the capacity to sequence 1,000 genomes in 2009 and
20,000 in 2010. That would represent a massive jump: with a price tag
of $100,000 to $1 million over the past two years, only a handful of
human genomes have been sequenced to date.
"Suddenly, these guys are talking about sequencing hundreds to thousands of genomes in the next couple of years," says Chad Nusbaum, codirector of the Genome Sequencing and Analysis program at the Broad Institute,
in Cambridge, MA. "That opens up tremendous vistas for the kind of
science we want to do. It's really by generating hundreds of
human-genome sequences that you can start to ask hard questions about
human genetics."
Complete Genomics says that it has already sequenced a human genome,
although it has not yet released the data for independent review.
"'Stunning' is not too strong a word, if they can do it in the very
near term," says Jeffrey Schloss, program director for technology
development at the U.S. National Human Genome Research Institute,
on the possibility of a $5,000 genome. "But I haven't seen any data and
I don't know anyone who has, which is of course critical."
J. Craig Venter, founder of the J. Craig Venter Institute,
in Rockville, MD, is working with Complete Genomics to validate its
technology, comparing the sequence that it generates with a reference
sequence of his own genome.
Complete Genomics says that its cheap price tag comes thanks to two innovations: a way to densely pack DNA, developed by Rade Drmanac,
the company's chief scientific officer, and a method to randomly read
DNA letters, based on sequencing technology developed at George Church's lab at Harvard.
To start with, an 80-base-pair piece of DNA is inserted into a
circular piece of synthetic DNA and replicated 1,000 times with a
specialized enzyme. That large aggregate of DNA spontaneously
compresses into a tightly packed ball, thanks to chemical
characteristics engineered into the synthetic DNA. These DNA
"nanoballs" are then packed onto specially fabricated arrays with
unprecedented density--about a billion balls fit on a chip the size of
a microscope slide. The high density of DNA allows large volumes to be
sequenced quickly with few reagents, one of the most costly components
of the process.
Next, as with other approaches, Complete Genomics determines the
sequence of the target DNA using a series of fluorescently labeled DNA
strands designed to bind to corresponding letters. But while advanced
sequencing technologies currently in use--including those from
Illumina, Applied Biosystems, and 454--read
the sequence sequentially, letter by letter, Complete Genomics's labels
bind to the target DNA randomly. Both the labels and the DNA circle are
designed to allow scientists to deduce the position of each highlighted
base--information that is then used to computationally reconstruct the
sequence of the target DNA. (With both Complete Genomics's and other
companies' methods, the short strands are computationally stitched
together to generate the entire genome sequence.)
Because the identification of each base in the sequence does not
depend on the correct identification of the previous one, individual
errors have less impact on the overall result, generating a more
accurate sequence with less repeat sequencing. (For a more detailed
explanation and schematic of Complete Genomics's sequencing process, click here.)
A $5,000 genome is likely to open new arenas in genetic study of
common disease. Most studies to date have analyzed carefully selected
portions of individuals' genomes, linking common variations to risk of
common ailments, such as diabetes and heart disease. However, even
studies of thousands of patients have uncovered genetic variations that
account for only a small percentage of the risk for disease. Scientists
say that the ability to sequence many people's genomes will allow them
to search for rare variations that likely account for remaining genetic
risk. "I'd love to get my hands on [this technology] and think about
how I can solve new problems with it," says Phil Sharp, MIT Institute Professor and winner of the 1993 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.
Beyond its unique technology, Complete Genomics has also chosen an
unusual business model: rather than selling instruments, as most
sequencing companies have done, it plans to offer sequencing services
through a commercial-scale genome center. Cliff Reid,
the company's president and chief executive officer, hopes that both
the service model and the price tag will appeal to those who don't want
to do their own sequencing, such as pharmaceutical companies. "They
don't want to purchase an instrument; they want to purchase data," says
Reid. In an effort to further pharmacogenomics--the ability to
prescribe the right drug at the right dose to a patient based on his or
her individual genetic profile--genomics is a growing component of
clinical trials.
The company is now building a massive data center to manage the
immense volume of information it expects to generate; it's planning to
have a computer cluster containing 60,000 processors online by 2010.
"No one has ever put together a data processing center this size for
sequencing--because no one has ever been able to sequence this many
genomes," says Reid. Complete Genomics will focus entirely on
human-genome sequencing, unlike other companies, which use their
technology for a variety of sequencing projects. And unlike Knome,
a personal-genomics startup that offers individuals a complete genome
sequence and personalized analysis for $350,000, Complete Genomics
provides only the genome sequence.
The company has already made its first deal: to sequence 100 genomes in 2009 and 2,000 genomes in 2010 for Leroy Hood
at the Institute for Systems Biology, in Seattle. Hood, who in the
1980s developed the first automated sequencing machine, sits on the
Complete Genomics advisory board. Hood's project will comprise about
ten percent of the facilities sequencing capacity in the first two
years.
Even if Complete Genomics faces up to its promises, "they face a lot
of competition," says J. Craig Venter. For example, Applied Biosystems,
a veteran in the sequencing industry, recently announced a
next-generation technology that it believes will be able to sequence
genomes for $10,000.
Copyright Technology Review 2008.